ANALYZING JUDGE ALITO'S VOTES: BY ISSUE

Cases involving any government agency or unit, except criminal cases

Cases in which Alito ruled against the government position: 14 cases

Case citationCase name
295 F.3d 390 Balsavage v. Director, Office of Workers' Compensation Programs
247 F.3d 34 Fargnoli v. Massanari
966 F.2d 747 Federal Labor Relations Authority v. U.S. Dept. of Navy
29 F.3d 833 FMC Corp. v. U.S. Dept. of Commerce
40 F.3d 669 N.L.R.B. v. Greensburg Coca-Cola Bottling Co., Inc.
13 F.3d 685 Reich v. Gateway Press, Inc.
115 F.3d 182 RNS Services, Inc. v. Secretary of Labor, Mine Safety and Health Admin. (MSHA)
294 F.3d 568 Thomas v. Commissioner of Social Sec.
138 Fed. Appx. 405 Thomas v. Fetzko
998 F.2d 1129 Ticor Title Ins. Co. v. F.T.C.
366 F.3d 164 U.S. v. Allegheny Ludlum Corp.
120 F.3d 437 U.S. v. Igbonwa
316 F.3d 392 United Artists Theatre Circuit, Inc. v. Township of Warrington, PA
261 F.3d 330 W.R. Grace & Co. v. U.S. E.P.A.

Cases in which Alito split his ruling: 10 cases

Case citationCase name
157 F.3d 231 ACM Partnership v. C.I.R.
82 F.3d 1291 Antol v. Perry
917 F.2d 115 Burden v. U.S.
364 F.3d 90 Hampe v. Butler
417 F.3d 408 Partyka v. Attorney General of U.S.
107 F.3d 164 Phillips v. Borough of Keyport
18 F.3d 1043 Rappa v. New Castle County
174 F.3d 305 Reform Party of Allegheny County v. Allegheny County Dept. of Elections
200 F.3d 101 Stanziale v. Jargowsky
2 F.3d 529 U.S. v. Premises Known as 717 South Woodward Street, Allentown, Pa.

Cases in which Alito ruled with the government position: 40 cases

Case citationCase name
163 F.3d 780 A.S. Goldmen & Co., Inc. v. New Jersey Bureau of Securities
239 F.3d 307 Abdul-Akbar v. McKelvie
110 F.3d 968 Azzaro v. County of Allegheny
399 F.3d 134 Banks v. Beard
119 F.3d 1055 Chang v. I.N.S.
83 Fed. Appx. 437 Conchatta, Inc. v. Evanko
353 F.3d 228 Dia v. Ashcroft
61 F.3d 170 Elizabeth Blackwell Health Center for Women v. Knoll
22 F.3d 1296 Fagan v. City of Vineland
46 F.3d 279 Fisher Bros. Sales, Inc. v. U.S.
283 F.3d 506 Fraise v. Terhune
989 F.2d 1332 Grant v. Shalala
47 F.3d 1342 Harris v. City of Philadelphia
256 F.3d 107 In re Four Three Oh, Inc.
335 F.3d 243 In re Hechinger Inv. Co. of Delaware, Inc.
116 F.3d 685 Jenkins v. Manning
368 F.3d 218 Lee v. Ashcroft
93 Fed. Appx. 333 Marwood v. Elizabeth Forward School Dist.
161 F.3d 117 Mellott v. Heemer
196 F.3d 160 Motley v. New Jersey State Police
212 F.3d 798 Nicini v. Morra
283 F.3d 531 Pennsylvania Pharmacists Ass'n v. Houstoun
88 F.3d 1300 Presbyterian University Hosp. v. N.L.R.B.
251 F.3d 448 Pryer v. C.O. 3 Slavic
983 F.2d 1215 Ramseur v. Beyer
57 F.3d 1231 Resolution Trust Corp. v. Cityfed Financial Corp.
130 Fed. Appx. 572 Rucci v. Cranberry Tp., Pa.
166 F.3d 225 Sandoval v. Reno
385 F.3d 293 Singh-Kaur v. Ashcroft
995 F.2d 404 Specter v. Garrett
962 F.2d 1110 St. Francis Medical Center v. Sullivan
223 F.3d 150 Suter v. Munich Reinsurance Co.
205 F.3d 572 T.R. v. Kingwood Tp. Bd. of Educ.
145 F.3d 625 Tara M. by Kantner v. City of Philadelphia
91 F.3d 1547 Taxman v. Board of Educ. of Tp. of Piscataway
20 F.3d 580 Tipu v. I.N.S.
186 F.3d 376 U.S. ex rel Mistick PBT v. Housing Authority of City of Pittsburgh
18 F.3d 1104 U.S. v. American Ins. Co.
202 F.3d 664 U.S. v. McGlory
213 F.3d 147 U.S. v. One Toshiba Color Television
© The Washington Post Company