ANALYZING JUDGE ALITO'S VOTES: BY ISSUE
Cases involving any government agency or unit, except criminal cases
- Cases in which Alito ruled against the government position (14 cases)
- Cases in which Alito split his ruling (10 cases)
- Cases in which Alito ruled with the government position (40 cases)
Cases in which Alito ruled against the government position: 14 cases
| Case citation | Case name |
|---|---|
| 295 F.3d 390 | Balsavage v. Director, Office of Workers' Compensation Programs |
| 247 F.3d 34 | Fargnoli v. Massanari |
| 966 F.2d 747 | Federal Labor Relations Authority v. U.S. Dept. of Navy |
| 29 F.3d 833 | FMC Corp. v. U.S. Dept. of Commerce |
| 40 F.3d 669 | N.L.R.B. v. Greensburg Coca-Cola Bottling Co., Inc. |
| 13 F.3d 685 | Reich v. Gateway Press, Inc. |
| 115 F.3d 182 | RNS Services, Inc. v. Secretary of Labor, Mine Safety and Health Admin. (MSHA) |
| 294 F.3d 568 | Thomas v. Commissioner of Social Sec. |
| 138 Fed. Appx. 405 | Thomas v. Fetzko |
| 998 F.2d 1129 | Ticor Title Ins. Co. v. F.T.C. |
| 366 F.3d 164 | U.S. v. Allegheny Ludlum Corp. |
| 120 F.3d 437 | U.S. v. Igbonwa |
| 316 F.3d 392 | United Artists Theatre Circuit, Inc. v. Township of Warrington, PA |
| 261 F.3d 330 | W.R. Grace & Co. v. U.S. E.P.A. |
Cases in which Alito split his ruling: 10 cases
| Case citation | Case name |
|---|---|
| 157 F.3d 231 | ACM Partnership v. C.I.R. |
| 82 F.3d 1291 | Antol v. Perry |
| 917 F.2d 115 | Burden v. U.S. |
| 364 F.3d 90 | Hampe v. Butler |
| 417 F.3d 408 | Partyka v. Attorney General of U.S. |
| 107 F.3d 164 | Phillips v. Borough of Keyport |
| 18 F.3d 1043 | Rappa v. New Castle County |
| 174 F.3d 305 | Reform Party of Allegheny County v. Allegheny County Dept. of Elections |
| 200 F.3d 101 | Stanziale v. Jargowsky |
| 2 F.3d 529 | U.S. v. Premises Known as 717 South Woodward Street, Allentown, Pa. |
Cases in which Alito ruled with the government position: 40 cases
| Case citation | Case name |
|---|---|
| 163 F.3d 780 | A.S. Goldmen & Co., Inc. v. New Jersey Bureau of Securities |
| 239 F.3d 307 | Abdul-Akbar v. McKelvie |
| 110 F.3d 968 | Azzaro v. County of Allegheny |
| 399 F.3d 134 | Banks v. Beard |
| 119 F.3d 1055 | Chang v. I.N.S. |
| 83 Fed. Appx. 437 | Conchatta, Inc. v. Evanko |
| 353 F.3d 228 | Dia v. Ashcroft |
| 61 F.3d 170 | Elizabeth Blackwell Health Center for Women v. Knoll |
| 22 F.3d 1296 | Fagan v. City of Vineland |
| 46 F.3d 279 | Fisher Bros. Sales, Inc. v. U.S. |
| 283 F.3d 506 | Fraise v. Terhune |
| 989 F.2d 1332 | Grant v. Shalala |
| 47 F.3d 1342 | Harris v. City of Philadelphia |
| 256 F.3d 107 | In re Four Three Oh, Inc. |
| 335 F.3d 243 | In re Hechinger Inv. Co. of Delaware, Inc. |
| 116 F.3d 685 | Jenkins v. Manning |
| 368 F.3d 218 | Lee v. Ashcroft |
| 93 Fed. Appx. 333 | Marwood v. Elizabeth Forward School Dist. |
| 161 F.3d 117 | Mellott v. Heemer |
| 196 F.3d 160 | Motley v. New Jersey State Police |
| 212 F.3d 798 | Nicini v. Morra |
| 283 F.3d 531 | Pennsylvania Pharmacists Ass'n v. Houstoun |
| 88 F.3d 1300 | Presbyterian University Hosp. v. N.L.R.B. |
| 251 F.3d 448 | Pryer v. C.O. 3 Slavic |
| 983 F.2d 1215 | Ramseur v. Beyer |
| 57 F.3d 1231 | Resolution Trust Corp. v. Cityfed Financial Corp. |
| 130 Fed. Appx. 572 | Rucci v. Cranberry Tp., Pa. |
| 166 F.3d 225 | Sandoval v. Reno |
| 385 F.3d 293 | Singh-Kaur v. Ashcroft |
| 995 F.2d 404 | Specter v. Garrett |
| 962 F.2d 1110 | St. Francis Medical Center v. Sullivan |
| 223 F.3d 150 | Suter v. Munich Reinsurance Co. |
| 205 F.3d 572 | T.R. v. Kingwood Tp. Bd. of Educ. |
| 145 F.3d 625 | Tara M. by Kantner v. City of Philadelphia |
| 91 F.3d 1547 | Taxman v. Board of Educ. of Tp. of Piscataway |
| 20 F.3d 580 | Tipu v. I.N.S. |
| 186 F.3d 376 | U.S. ex rel Mistick PBT v. Housing Authority of City of Pittsburgh |
| 18 F.3d 1104 | U.S. v. American Ins. Co. |
| 202 F.3d 664 | U.S. v. McGlory |
| 213 F.3d 147 | U.S. v. One Toshiba Color Television |
© The Washington Post Company