Vote 224

Question: Whether the Amendment is Germane
Category: Motion
Vote description: Is Amdt. No. 3980 Germane to H.R. 4461; To clarify the effect of the provision prohibiting amendment of part 3809 of title 43, Code of Federal Regulations.
Vote type: 1/2 (Help)
A simple majority of those present and voting is required for approval or passage.
Result: Not Germane, 36-56, with 7 not voting.
Date/time: July 20, 2000, 8:53 p.m.
Amendment num: S.Amdt. 3980
Republican majority opinion: No (Help)
The position of more than 50 percent of voting Republicans. "None" means an equal split between "Yes" and "No."
Democrat majority opinion: Yes (Help)
The position of more than 50 percent of voting Democrats. "None" means an equal split between "Yes" and "No."

Vote totals

Click to list individual members.

	Yes	No	Not Voting
Aquarius	Judd Gregg, Herb Kohl, Frank Lautenberg, Paul Sarbanes, Arlen Specter	Conrad Burns, Mike Enzi, Rod Grams, Craig Thomas, John Warner
Aries	Lincoln Chafee, Patrick Leahy	Ben Campbell, Orrin Hatch, Richard Lugar, Frank Murkowski, Robert Smith
Cancer	Dianne Feinstein, Carl Levin, Chuck Robb, William Roth, George Voinovich, Paul Wellstone	Richard Bryan, Larry Craig, Phil Gramm, Kay Bailey Hutchison, Barbara Mikulski
Capricorn	Evan Bayh, Tim Johnson	Mike DeWine, Slade Gorton, Fritz Hollings, Jeff Sessions
Gemini	Chris Dodd, John Edwards, Jay Rockefeller	Spencer Abraham, Gordon Smith
Leo		Timothy Hutchinson, Fred Thompson
Libra	Peter Fitzgerald, Blanche Lincoln	Jeff Bingaman, Chuck Hagel, Jesse Helms, Trent Lott	Patty Murray
Pisces	Russ Feingold, Joseph Lieberman, Olympia Snowe	Kit Bond, John Breaux, Kent Conrad, Bill Frist, Mitch McConnell, Daniel Moynihan	Edward Kennedy
Sagittarius	Susan Collins, Mary Landrieu, Chuck Schumer	Wayne Allard, Max Baucus, Thad Cochran, Tom Daschle, Donald Nickles, Harry Reid, Strom Thurmond	John Kerry
Scorpio	Joe Biden, Dick Durbin, Bob Graham, Tom Harkin, Jack Reed	Robert Byrd, James Inhofe, Connie Mack, Ted Stevens	Barbara Boxer, Jim Bunning
Taurus	James Jeffords, Ron Wyden	John Ashcroft, Mike Crapo, Pete Domenici, Byron Dorgan, Jon Kyl, Pat Roberts, Rick Santorum, Richard Shelby
Virgo	Daniel Akaka, Max Cleland, Bob Torricelli	Bob Bennett, Sam Brownback, Chuck Grassley, John McCain	Daniel Inouye, Bob Kerrey

	Yes	No	Not Voting
Female	Susan Collins, Dianne Feinstein, Mary Landrieu, Blanche Lincoln, Olympia Snowe	Kay Bailey Hutchison, Barbara Mikulski	Barbara Boxer, Patty Murray
Male	Daniel Akaka, Evan Bayh, Joe Biden, Lincoln Chafee, Max Cleland, Chris Dodd, Dick Durbin, John Edwards, Russ Feingold, Peter Fitzgerald, Bob Graham, Judd Gregg, Tom Harkin, James Jeffords, Tim Johnson, Herb Kohl, Frank Lautenberg, Patrick Leahy, Carl Levin, Joseph Lieberman, Jack Reed, Chuck Robb, Jay Rockefeller, William Roth, Paul Sarbanes, Chuck Schumer, Arlen Specter, Bob Torricelli, George Voinovich, Paul Wellstone, Ron Wyden	Spencer Abraham, Wayne Allard, John Ashcroft, Max Baucus, Bob Bennett, Jeff Bingaman, Kit Bond, John Breaux, Sam Brownback, Richard Bryan, Conrad Burns, Robert Byrd, Ben Campbell, Thad Cochran, Kent Conrad, Larry Craig, Mike Crapo, Tom Daschle, Mike DeWine, Pete Domenici, Byron Dorgan, Mike Enzi, Bill Frist, Slade Gorton, Phil Gramm, Rod Grams, Chuck Grassley, Chuck Hagel, Orrin Hatch, Jesse Helms, Fritz Hollings, Timothy Hutchinson, James Inhofe, Jon Kyl, Trent Lott, Richard Lugar, Connie Mack, John McCain, Mitch McConnell, Daniel Moynihan, Frank Murkowski, Donald Nickles, Harry Reid, Pat Roberts, Rick Santorum, Jeff Sessions, Richard Shelby, Robert Smith, Gordon Smith, Ted Stevens, Craig Thomas, Fred Thompson, Strom Thurmond, John Warner	Jim Bunning, Daniel Inouye, Edward Kennedy, Bob Kerrey, John Kerry

	Yes	No	Not Voting
Midwest	Evan Bayh, Dick Durbin, Russ Feingold, Peter Fitzgerald, Tom Harkin, Tim Johnson, Herb Kohl, Carl Levin, George Voinovich, Paul Wellstone	Spencer Abraham, John Ashcroft, Kit Bond, Sam Brownback, Kent Conrad, Tom Daschle, Mike DeWine, Byron Dorgan, Rod Grams, Chuck Grassley, Chuck Hagel, Richard Lugar, Pat Roberts	Bob Kerrey
Northeast	Lincoln Chafee, Susan Collins, Chris Dodd, Judd Gregg, James Jeffords, Frank Lautenberg, Patrick Leahy, Joseph Lieberman, Jack Reed, Chuck Schumer, Olympia Snowe, Arlen Specter, Bob Torricelli	Daniel Moynihan, Rick Santorum, Robert Smith	Edward Kennedy, John Kerry
South	Joe Biden, Max Cleland, John Edwards, Bob Graham, Mary Landrieu, Blanche Lincoln, Chuck Robb, Jay Rockefeller, William Roth, Paul Sarbanes	John Breaux, Robert Byrd, Thad Cochran, Bill Frist, Phil Gramm, Jesse Helms, Fritz Hollings, Timothy Hutchinson, Kay Bailey Hutchison, James Inhofe, Trent Lott, Connie Mack, Mitch McConnell, Barbara Mikulski, Donald Nickles, Jeff Sessions, Richard Shelby, Fred Thompson, Strom Thurmond, John Warner	Jim Bunning
West	Daniel Akaka, Dianne Feinstein, Ron Wyden	Wayne Allard, Max Baucus, Bob Bennett, Jeff Bingaman, Richard Bryan, Conrad Burns, Ben Campbell, Larry Craig, Mike Crapo, Pete Domenici, Mike Enzi, Slade Gorton, Orrin Hatch, Jon Kyl, John McCain, Frank Murkowski, Harry Reid, Gordon Smith, Ted Stevens, Craig Thomas	Barbara Boxer, Daniel Inouye, Patty Murray

	Yes	No	Not Voting
None	Max Cleland, John Edwards, Peter Fitzgerald, Bob Graham, Chuck Robb, William Roth, Bob Torricelli, Paul Wellstone	Spencer Abraham, John Ashcroft, John Breaux, Richard Bryan, Ben Campbell, Tom Daschle, Slade Gorton, Phil Gramm, Rod Grams, Jesse Helms, Fritz Hollings, Timothy Hutchinson, Connie Mack, Daniel Moynihan, Frank Murkowski, Donald Nickles, Robert Smith, Fred Thompson, Strom Thurmond	Bob Kerrey
2006	Lincoln Chafee, James Jeffords, Paul Sarbanes	Conrad Burns, Mike DeWine, Bill Frist, Rick Santorum
2008	Joe Biden, Susan Collins, Dick Durbin, Tom Harkin, Tim Johnson, Mary Landrieu, Frank Lautenberg, Carl Levin, Jack Reed, Jay Rockefeller	Wayne Allard, Max Baucus, Thad Cochran, Larry Craig, Pete Domenici, Mike Enzi, Chuck Hagel, James Inhofe, Mitch McConnell, Pat Roberts, Jeff Sessions, Gordon Smith, Ted Stevens, John Warner	John Kerry
2010	Evan Bayh, Chris Dodd, Russ Feingold, Judd Gregg, Patrick Leahy, Blanche Lincoln, Chuck Schumer, Arlen Specter, George Voinovich, Ron Wyden	Bob Bennett, Kit Bond, Sam Brownback, Mike Crapo, Byron Dorgan, Chuck Grassley, John McCain, Barbara Mikulski, Harry Reid, Richard Shelby	Barbara Boxer, Jim Bunning, Daniel Inouye, Patty Murray
2012	Daniel Akaka, Dianne Feinstein, Herb Kohl, Joseph Lieberman, Olympia Snowe	Jeff Bingaman, Robert Byrd, Kent Conrad, Orrin Hatch, Kay Bailey Hutchison, Jon Kyl, Trent Lott, Richard Lugar, Craig Thomas	Edward Kennedy

	Yes	No	Not Voting
Alabama		Jeff Sessions, Richard Shelby
Alaska		Frank Murkowski, Ted Stevens
Arizona		Jon Kyl, John McCain
Arkansas	Blanche Lincoln	Timothy Hutchinson
California	Dianne Feinstein		Barbara Boxer
Colorado		Wayne Allard, Ben Campbell
Connecticut	Chris Dodd, Joseph Lieberman
Delaware	Joe Biden, William Roth
Florida	Bob Graham	Connie Mack
Georgia	Max Cleland
Hawaii	Daniel Akaka		Daniel Inouye
Idaho		Larry Craig, Mike Crapo
Illinois	Dick Durbin, Peter Fitzgerald
Indiana	Evan Bayh	Richard Lugar
Iowa	Tom Harkin	Chuck Grassley
Kansas		Sam Brownback, Pat Roberts
Kentucky		Mitch McConnell	Jim Bunning
Louisiana	Mary Landrieu	John Breaux
Maine	Susan Collins, Olympia Snowe
Maryland	Paul Sarbanes	Barbara Mikulski
Massachusetts			Edward Kennedy, John Kerry
Michigan	Carl Levin	Spencer Abraham
Minnesota	Paul Wellstone	Rod Grams
Mississippi		Thad Cochran, Trent Lott
Missouri		John Ashcroft, Kit Bond
Montana		Max Baucus, Conrad Burns
Nebraska		Chuck Hagel	Bob Kerrey
Nevada		Richard Bryan, Harry Reid
New Hampshire	Judd Gregg	Robert Smith
New Jersey	Frank Lautenberg, Bob Torricelli
New Mexico		Jeff Bingaman, Pete Domenici
New York	Chuck Schumer	Daniel Moynihan
North Carolina	John Edwards	Jesse Helms
North Dakota		Kent Conrad, Byron Dorgan
Ohio	George Voinovich	Mike DeWine
Oklahoma		James Inhofe, Donald Nickles
Oregon	Ron Wyden	Gordon Smith
Pennsylvania	Arlen Specter	Rick Santorum
Rhode Island	Lincoln Chafee, Jack Reed
South Carolina		Fritz Hollings, Strom Thurmond
South Dakota	Tim Johnson	Tom Daschle
Tennessee		Bill Frist, Fred Thompson
Texas		Phil Gramm, Kay Bailey Hutchison
Utah		Bob Bennett, Orrin Hatch
Vermont	James Jeffords, Patrick Leahy
Virginia	Chuck Robb	John Warner
Washington		Slade Gorton	Patty Murray
West Virginia	Jay Rockefeller	Robert Byrd
Wisconsin	Russ Feingold, Herb Kohl
Wyoming		Mike Enzi, Craig Thomas

	Yes	No	Not Voting
Baby boomer	Evan Bayh, Lincoln Chafee, Susan Collins, John Edwards, Russ Feingold, Peter Fitzgerald, Judd Gregg, Tim Johnson, Mary Landrieu, Blanche Lincoln, Jack Reed, Chuck Schumer, Olympia Snowe, Bob Torricelli, Ron Wyden	Spencer Abraham, Sam Brownback, Kent Conrad, Mike Crapo, Tom Daschle, Mike DeWine, Bill Frist, Rod Grams, Chuck Hagel, Timothy Hutchinson, Donald Nickles, Rick Santorum, Jeff Sessions, Gordon Smith	Patty Murray
Pre-boomer	Daniel Akaka, Joe Biden, Max Cleland, Chris Dodd, Dick Durbin, Dianne Feinstein, Bob Graham, Tom Harkin, James Jeffords, Herb Kohl, Frank Lautenberg, Patrick Leahy, Carl Levin, Joseph Lieberman, Chuck Robb, Jay Rockefeller, William Roth, Paul Sarbanes, Arlen Specter, George Voinovich, Paul Wellstone	Wayne Allard, John Ashcroft, Max Baucus, Bob Bennett, Jeff Bingaman, Kit Bond, John Breaux, Richard Bryan, Conrad Burns, Robert Byrd, Ben Campbell, Thad Cochran, Larry Craig, Pete Domenici, Byron Dorgan, Mike Enzi, Slade Gorton, Phil Gramm, Chuck Grassley, Orrin Hatch, Jesse Helms, Fritz Hollings, Kay Bailey Hutchison, James Inhofe, Jon Kyl, Trent Lott, Richard Lugar, Connie Mack, John McCain, Mitch McConnell, Barbara Mikulski, Daniel Moynihan, Frank Murkowski, Harry Reid, Pat Roberts, Richard Shelby, Robert Smith, Ted Stevens, Craig Thomas, Fred Thompson, Strom Thurmond, John Warner	Barbara Boxer, Jim Bunning, Daniel Inouye, Edward Kennedy, Bob Kerrey, John Kerry

	Yes	No	Not Voting
Democratic	Daniel Akaka, Evan Bayh, Joe Biden, Max Cleland, Chris Dodd, Dick Durbin, John Edwards, Russ Feingold, Dianne Feinstein, Bob Graham, Tom Harkin, Tim Johnson, Herb Kohl, Mary Landrieu, Frank Lautenberg, Patrick Leahy, Carl Levin, Joseph Lieberman, Blanche Lincoln, Jack Reed, Chuck Robb, Jay Rockefeller, Paul Sarbanes, Chuck Schumer, Bob Torricelli, Paul Wellstone, Ron Wyden	Max Baucus, Jeff Bingaman, John Breaux, Richard Bryan, Robert Byrd, Kent Conrad, Tom Daschle, Byron Dorgan, Fritz Hollings, Barbara Mikulski, Daniel Moynihan, Harry Reid	Barbara Boxer, Daniel Inouye, Edward Kennedy, Bob Kerrey, John Kerry, Patty Murray
Republican	Lincoln Chafee, Susan Collins, Peter Fitzgerald, Judd Gregg, James Jeffords, William Roth, Olympia Snowe, Arlen Specter, George Voinovich	Spencer Abraham, Wayne Allard, John Ashcroft, Bob Bennett, Kit Bond, Sam Brownback, Conrad Burns, Ben Campbell, Thad Cochran, Larry Craig, Mike Crapo, Mike DeWine, Pete Domenici, Mike Enzi, Bill Frist, Slade Gorton, Phil Gramm, Rod Grams, Chuck Grassley, Chuck Hagel, Orrin Hatch, Jesse Helms, Timothy Hutchinson, Kay Bailey Hutchison, James Inhofe, Jon Kyl, Trent Lott, Richard Lugar, Connie Mack, John McCain, Mitch McConnell, Frank Murkowski, Donald Nickles, Pat Roberts, Rick Santorum, Jeff Sessions, Richard Shelby, Robert Smith, Gordon Smith, Ted Stevens, Craig Thomas, Fred Thompson, Strom Thurmond, John Warner	Jim Bunning