Vote 12

Question: On the Point of Order
Category: Motion
Vote description: Motion To Waive C.B.A. Re: Inhofe Amdt No 2285 and S. 1072; To provide a complete substitute.
Vote type: 3/5 (Help)
A three-fifths majority of those present and voting is required for approval or passage. Used in the Senate.
Result: Not Sustained, 72-24, with 4 not voting.
Date/time: February 12, 2004, 2:39 p.m.
Amendment num: S.Amdt. 2285
Republican majority opinion: Yes (Help)
The position of more than 50 percent of voting Republicans. "None" means an equal split between "Yes" and "No."
Democrat majority opinion: Yes (Help)
The position of more than 50 percent of voting Democrats. "None" means an equal split between "Yes" and "No."

Vote totals

Click to list individual members.

	Yes	No	Not Voting
Aquarius	Tom Carper, John Cornyn, Mark Dayton, Frank Lautenberg, Paul Sarbanes, Craig Thomas, John Warner	Conrad Burns, Mike Enzi, Judd Gregg, Herb Kohl	Arlen Specter
Aries	Ben Campbell, Lincoln Chafee, Orrin Hatch, Patrick Leahy	John Ensign, Richard Lugar
Cancer	Dianne Feinstein, Carl Levin, Barbara Mikulski, George Voinovich	Lamar Alexander, Larry Craig, Lindsey Graham, Kay Bailey Hutchison
Capricorn	Jon Corzine, Mike DeWine, Fritz Hollings, Tim Johnson, Mark Pryor	Evan Bayh, Jeff Sessions
Gemini	Chris Dodd, Lisa Murkowski, Jay Rockefeller, Gordon Smith		John Edwards
Leo	Norm Coleman, Liddy Dole
Libra	Jeff Bingaman, Maria Cantwell, Blanche Lincoln, Trent Lott, Patty Murray, Bill Nelson, Jim Talent	Peter Fitzgerald, Chuck Hagel
Pisces	George Allen, Kit Bond, John Breaux, Kent Conrad, Bill Frist, Edward Kennedy, Joseph Lieberman, Mitch McConnell, Olympia Snowe	Russ Feingold, Zell Miller
Sagittarius	Max Baucus, Thad Cochran, Susan Collins, Tom Daschle, Mary Landrieu, Harry Reid, Chuck Schumer	Wayne Allard, Donald Nickles	John Kerry
Scorpio	Joe Biden, Barbara Boxer, Jim Bunning, Robert Byrd, Hillary Clinton, Dick Durbin, Tom Harkin, James Inhofe, Jack Reed, Ted Stevens	Saxby Chambliss	Bob Graham
Taurus	Mike Crapo, Pete Domenici, Byron Dorgan, James Jeffords, Ben Nelson, Pat Roberts, Richard Shelby, Debbie Stabenow, Ron Wyden	Jon Kyl, Rick Santorum
Virgo	Daniel Akaka, Bob Bennett, Chuck Grassley, Daniel Inouye	Sam Brownback, John McCain, John Sununu

	Yes	No	Not Voting
Female	Barbara Boxer, Maria Cantwell, Hillary Clinton, Susan Collins, Liddy Dole, Dianne Feinstein, Mary Landrieu, Blanche Lincoln, Barbara Mikulski, Lisa Murkowski, Patty Murray, Olympia Snowe, Debbie Stabenow	Kay Bailey Hutchison
Male	Daniel Akaka, George Allen, Max Baucus, Bob Bennett, Joe Biden, Jeff Bingaman, Kit Bond, John Breaux, Jim Bunning, Robert Byrd, Ben Campbell, Tom Carper, Lincoln Chafee, Thad Cochran, Norm Coleman, Kent Conrad, John Cornyn, Jon Corzine, Mike Crapo, Tom Daschle, Mark Dayton, Mike DeWine, Chris Dodd, Pete Domenici, Byron Dorgan, Dick Durbin, Bill Frist, Chuck Grassley, Tom Harkin, Orrin Hatch, Fritz Hollings, James Inhofe, Daniel Inouye, James Jeffords, Tim Johnson, Edward Kennedy, Frank Lautenberg, Patrick Leahy, Carl Levin, Joseph Lieberman, Trent Lott, Mitch McConnell, Bill Nelson, Ben Nelson, Mark Pryor, Jack Reed, Harry Reid, Pat Roberts, Jay Rockefeller, Paul Sarbanes, Chuck Schumer, Richard Shelby, Gordon Smith, Ted Stevens, Jim Talent, Craig Thomas, George Voinovich, John Warner, Ron Wyden	Lamar Alexander, Wayne Allard, Evan Bayh, Sam Brownback, Conrad Burns, Saxby Chambliss, Larry Craig, John Ensign, Mike Enzi, Russ Feingold, Peter Fitzgerald, Lindsey Graham, Judd Gregg, Chuck Hagel, Herb Kohl, Jon Kyl, Richard Lugar, John McCain, Zell Miller, Donald Nickles, Rick Santorum, Jeff Sessions, John Sununu	John Edwards, Bob Graham, John Kerry, Arlen Specter

	Yes	No	Not Voting
Midwest	Kit Bond, Norm Coleman, Kent Conrad, Tom Daschle, Mark Dayton, Mike DeWine, Byron Dorgan, Dick Durbin, Chuck Grassley, Tom Harkin, Tim Johnson, Carl Levin, Ben Nelson, Pat Roberts, Debbie Stabenow, Jim Talent, George Voinovich	Evan Bayh, Sam Brownback, Russ Feingold, Peter Fitzgerald, Chuck Hagel, Herb Kohl, Richard Lugar
Northeast	Lincoln Chafee, Hillary Clinton, Susan Collins, Jon Corzine, Chris Dodd, James Jeffords, Edward Kennedy, Frank Lautenberg, Patrick Leahy, Joseph Lieberman, Jack Reed, Chuck Schumer, Olympia Snowe	Judd Gregg, Rick Santorum, John Sununu	John Kerry, Arlen Specter
South	George Allen, Joe Biden, John Breaux, Jim Bunning, Robert Byrd, Tom Carper, Thad Cochran, John Cornyn, Liddy Dole, Bill Frist, Fritz Hollings, James Inhofe, Mary Landrieu, Blanche Lincoln, Trent Lott, Mitch McConnell, Barbara Mikulski, Bill Nelson, Mark Pryor, Jay Rockefeller, Paul Sarbanes, Richard Shelby, John Warner	Lamar Alexander, Saxby Chambliss, Lindsey Graham, Kay Bailey Hutchison, Zell Miller, Donald Nickles, Jeff Sessions	John Edwards, Bob Graham
West	Daniel Akaka, Max Baucus, Bob Bennett, Jeff Bingaman, Barbara Boxer, Ben Campbell, Maria Cantwell, Mike Crapo, Pete Domenici, Dianne Feinstein, Orrin Hatch, Daniel Inouye, Lisa Murkowski, Patty Murray, Harry Reid, Gordon Smith, Ted Stevens, Craig Thomas, Ron Wyden	Wayne Allard, Conrad Burns, Larry Craig, John Ensign, Mike Enzi, Jon Kyl, John McCain

	Yes	No	Not Voting
None	John Breaux, Ben Campbell, Jon Corzine, Tom Daschle, Fritz Hollings	Peter Fitzgerald, Zell Miller, Donald Nickles	John Edwards, Bob Graham
2006	George Allen, Lincoln Chafee, Mark Dayton, Mike DeWine, Bill Frist, James Jeffords, Paul Sarbanes, Jim Talent	Conrad Burns, Rick Santorum
2008	Max Baucus, Joe Biden, Thad Cochran, Norm Coleman, Susan Collins, John Cornyn, Liddy Dole, Pete Domenici, Dick Durbin, Tom Harkin, James Inhofe, Tim Johnson, Mary Landrieu, Frank Lautenberg, Carl Levin, Mitch McConnell, Mark Pryor, Jack Reed, Pat Roberts, Jay Rockefeller, Gordon Smith, Ted Stevens, John Warner	Lamar Alexander, Wayne Allard, Saxby Chambliss, Larry Craig, Mike Enzi, Lindsey Graham, Chuck Hagel, Jeff Sessions, John Sununu	John Kerry
2010	Bob Bennett, Kit Bond, Barbara Boxer, Jim Bunning, Mike Crapo, Chris Dodd, Byron Dorgan, Chuck Grassley, Daniel Inouye, Patrick Leahy, Blanche Lincoln, Barbara Mikulski, Lisa Murkowski, Patty Murray, Harry Reid, Chuck Schumer, Richard Shelby, George Voinovich, Ron Wyden	Evan Bayh, Sam Brownback, Russ Feingold, Judd Gregg, John McCain	Arlen Specter
2012	Daniel Akaka, Jeff Bingaman, Robert Byrd, Maria Cantwell, Tom Carper, Hillary Clinton, Kent Conrad, Dianne Feinstein, Orrin Hatch, Edward Kennedy, Joseph Lieberman, Trent Lott, Bill Nelson, Ben Nelson, Olympia Snowe, Debbie Stabenow, Craig Thomas	John Ensign, Kay Bailey Hutchison, Herb Kohl, Jon Kyl, Richard Lugar

	Yes	No	Not Voting
Alabama	Richard Shelby	Jeff Sessions
Alaska	Lisa Murkowski, Ted Stevens
Arizona		Jon Kyl, John McCain
Arkansas	Blanche Lincoln, Mark Pryor
California	Barbara Boxer, Dianne Feinstein
Colorado	Ben Campbell	Wayne Allard
Connecticut	Chris Dodd, Joseph Lieberman
Delaware	Joe Biden, Tom Carper
Florida	Bill Nelson		Bob Graham
Georgia		Saxby Chambliss, Zell Miller
Hawaii	Daniel Akaka, Daniel Inouye
Idaho	Mike Crapo	Larry Craig
Illinois	Dick Durbin	Peter Fitzgerald
Indiana		Evan Bayh, Richard Lugar
Iowa	Chuck Grassley, Tom Harkin
Kansas	Pat Roberts	Sam Brownback
Kentucky	Jim Bunning, Mitch McConnell
Louisiana	John Breaux, Mary Landrieu
Maine	Susan Collins, Olympia Snowe
Maryland	Barbara Mikulski, Paul Sarbanes
Massachusetts	Edward Kennedy		John Kerry
Michigan	Carl Levin, Debbie Stabenow
Minnesota	Norm Coleman, Mark Dayton
Mississippi	Thad Cochran, Trent Lott
Missouri	Kit Bond, Jim Talent
Montana	Max Baucus	Conrad Burns
Nebraska	Ben Nelson	Chuck Hagel
Nevada	Harry Reid	John Ensign
New Hampshire		Judd Gregg, John Sununu
New Jersey	Jon Corzine, Frank Lautenberg
New Mexico	Jeff Bingaman, Pete Domenici
New York	Hillary Clinton, Chuck Schumer
North Carolina	Liddy Dole		John Edwards
North Dakota	Kent Conrad, Byron Dorgan
Ohio	Mike DeWine, George Voinovich
Oklahoma	James Inhofe	Donald Nickles
Oregon	Gordon Smith, Ron Wyden
Pennsylvania		Rick Santorum	Arlen Specter
Rhode Island	Lincoln Chafee, Jack Reed
South Carolina	Fritz Hollings	Lindsey Graham
South Dakota	Tom Daschle, Tim Johnson
Tennessee	Bill Frist	Lamar Alexander
Texas	John Cornyn	Kay Bailey Hutchison
Utah	Bob Bennett, Orrin Hatch
Vermont	James Jeffords, Patrick Leahy
Virginia	George Allen, John Warner
Washington	Maria Cantwell, Patty Murray
West Virginia	Robert Byrd, Jay Rockefeller
Wisconsin		Russ Feingold, Herb Kohl
Wyoming	Craig Thomas	Mike Enzi

	Yes	No	Not Voting
Baby boomer	George Allen, Maria Cantwell, Tom Carper, Lincoln Chafee, Hillary Clinton, Norm Coleman, Susan Collins, Kent Conrad, John Cornyn, Jon Corzine, Mike Crapo, Tom Daschle, Mark Dayton, Mike DeWine, Bill Frist, Tim Johnson, Mary Landrieu, Blanche Lincoln, Lisa Murkowski, Patty Murray, Mark Pryor, Jack Reed, Chuck Schumer, Gordon Smith, Olympia Snowe, Debbie Stabenow, Jim Talent, Ron Wyden	Evan Bayh, Sam Brownback, John Ensign, Russ Feingold, Peter Fitzgerald, Lindsey Graham, Judd Gregg, Chuck Hagel, Donald Nickles, Rick Santorum, Jeff Sessions, John Sununu	John Edwards
Pre-boomer	Daniel Akaka, Max Baucus, Bob Bennett, Joe Biden, Jeff Bingaman, Kit Bond, Barbara Boxer, John Breaux, Jim Bunning, Robert Byrd, Ben Campbell, Thad Cochran, Chris Dodd, Liddy Dole, Pete Domenici, Byron Dorgan, Dick Durbin, Dianne Feinstein, Chuck Grassley, Tom Harkin, Orrin Hatch, Fritz Hollings, James Inhofe, Daniel Inouye, James Jeffords, Edward Kennedy, Frank Lautenberg, Patrick Leahy, Carl Levin, Joseph Lieberman, Trent Lott, Mitch McConnell, Barbara Mikulski, Bill Nelson, Ben Nelson, Harry Reid, Pat Roberts, Jay Rockefeller, Paul Sarbanes, Richard Shelby, Ted Stevens, Craig Thomas, George Voinovich, John Warner	Lamar Alexander, Wayne Allard, Conrad Burns, Saxby Chambliss, Larry Craig, Mike Enzi, Kay Bailey Hutchison, Herb Kohl, Jon Kyl, Richard Lugar, John McCain, Zell Miller	Bob Graham, John Kerry, Arlen Specter

	Yes	No	Not Voting
Democratic	Daniel Akaka, Max Baucus, Joe Biden, Jeff Bingaman, Barbara Boxer, John Breaux, Robert Byrd, Maria Cantwell, Tom Carper, Hillary Clinton, Kent Conrad, Jon Corzine, Tom Daschle, Mark Dayton, Chris Dodd, Byron Dorgan, Dick Durbin, Dianne Feinstein, Tom Harkin, Fritz Hollings, Daniel Inouye, Tim Johnson, Edward Kennedy, Mary Landrieu, Frank Lautenberg, Patrick Leahy, Carl Levin, Joseph Lieberman, Blanche Lincoln, Barbara Mikulski, Patty Murray, Bill Nelson, Ben Nelson, Mark Pryor, Jack Reed, Harry Reid, Jay Rockefeller, Paul Sarbanes, Chuck Schumer, Debbie Stabenow, Ron Wyden	Evan Bayh, Russ Feingold, Herb Kohl, Zell Miller	John Edwards, Bob Graham, John Kerry
Independent	James Jeffords
Republican	George Allen, Bob Bennett, Kit Bond, Jim Bunning, Ben Campbell, Lincoln Chafee, Thad Cochran, Norm Coleman, Susan Collins, John Cornyn, Mike Crapo, Mike DeWine, Liddy Dole, Pete Domenici, Bill Frist, Chuck Grassley, Orrin Hatch, James Inhofe, Trent Lott, Mitch McConnell, Lisa Murkowski, Pat Roberts, Richard Shelby, Gordon Smith, Olympia Snowe, Ted Stevens, Jim Talent, Craig Thomas, George Voinovich, John Warner	Lamar Alexander, Wayne Allard, Sam Brownback, Conrad Burns, Saxby Chambliss, Larry Craig, John Ensign, Mike Enzi, Peter Fitzgerald, Lindsey Graham, Judd Gregg, Chuck Hagel, Kay Bailey Hutchison, Jon Kyl, Richard Lugar, John McCain, Donald Nickles, Rick Santorum, Jeff Sessions, John Sununu	Arlen Specter